marchetti.pdf
(
416 KB
)
Pobierz
26319520 UNPDF
1
Emanuela Marchetti
Viking Denmark and Early Medieval Italy: a possibility for a
comparison
Introduction
Signs of cultural and economic change can be traced in the transformation of settlement patterns, given
that their structure was usually determined by inhabitants and political authorities interested in controlling
and economically exploiting the territory.
Therefore it could be relevant to discover which important transformations in settlement patterns were
taking place in different areas of Europe during the same chronological period. In Romance Europe when
the feudal system was already in use, a new concept emerged in the administration of land property, the so-
called
incastellamento
, implemented by local landowners (nobles or clergymen) in order to display their
personal power and wealth.
The decadence of the Roman
villa
system generated a situation of instability, and as a consequence
settlements were abandoned or reorganized around a new centre, the castle, so that they would be
protected and controlled in a more efficient way.
However, during the research for my master thesis,
1
it was possible to verify that similar dynamics were
recognizable also during the Viking Age in Denmark. Danish aristocratic manors and Italian castles had a
similar history: they were both first residences for landlords, and then they became real settlements with
military, commercial, and productive activities within their walls.
Moreover towns in Denmark had been founded since the late Viking Age (around the tenth-eleventh
centuries), often in places already in use for commercial or political purposes. Before towns all the
Ennen ja nyt 4/2004 >>>
http://www.ennenjanyt.net/4-04/merchetti.pdf
2
productive activities were usually limited to the domestic sphere. Towns offered a new environment more
similar to the one known in other European areas.
In Italy the situation was different. Towns and bigger cities were inherited from the Roman Age with a
long tradition derived from Greek colonies and Etruscan areas. But during the Middle Ages Italian towns
were in decline, suffering a deep crisis related to economic and political problems.
After having a look at similar examples, I think that Viking Age in Denmark and the Early Middle Ages in
Italy (more or less from 800 until 1100-1200) were both a period of experimentation, with changes in
economy, society and, as a consequence, in settlement pattern.
Therefore this article presents a possibility to compare early medieval Italy and Viking Age Denmark, two
realities traditionally considered very different from the point of view of transformations of settlements
patterns. I believe that such a study could be useful in order to better understand what was happening in
medieval Europe concerning the relationship between social background, settlement patterns, and the
adoption of new models. My aim is to here make a base for a comparative study, discussing structural
analogies of settlement patterns and building technique, introducing only some issues related to social and
political background, which could be treated more efficiently in further research.
I hope to be able to refer to these analogies in the future, extending this comparison to Scandinavia and
other areas in Southern Europe; therefore I am introducing a formal approach, in order to individuate valid
elements extracted from the structure of settlements. This approach basically consists of a system of five
parameters freely inspired by Weber's ideal-types method, as presented by David L. D'Avray.
2
In the following section, I present settlement patterns in Italy and Denmark by showing the most discussed
settlements, in order to offer a general overview, focusing on chronology, archaeological data, and related
problems.
The third section describes my method of analysis in order to obtain a more systematic point of view. My
method is then applied in the fourth section, where settlements from Italy and Denmark are discussed
from a comparative perspective in order to research analogies and differences; and in the fifth section
Ennen ja nyt 4/2004 >>>
http://www.ennenjanyt.net/4-04/merchetti.pdf
3
conclusions and possible future research is presented.
General overview: looking for analogies between Denmark and Italy
This article has as its main point to compare the Viking Age in Denmark and the Early Middle Ages in
Italy; I have already fixed the geographical context, presented by the territorial extension of Denmark and
Italy, more or less as they are today. It could be interesting to find a chronological frame in which to study
changes in settlement patterns, as a process. I will start to look at the two countries and the two periods
separately, analysing their individual limits as defined by the previously conducted studies.
Traditionally the Early Middle Ages in Italy is supposed to have begun in 476, with the fall of the Western
Roman Empire and the deposition of the last emperor, the young Romulus Augustulus, by the barbarian
Odoacer. From that moment the Western Roman Empire was officially decayed and new entities were to
replace it, the so-called Roman-Barbarian kingdoms, with a mixed population (Latin and Barbarian) ruled
by barbarian kings; only the Eastern Roman Empire survived, with its capital in Byzantium.
3
This period has traditionally been called the Middle Ages by historians, in opposition to the Roman Age,
and the result was a polarization: the Roman Age was described as an advanced time, with a good lifestyle,
sophisticated culture, and an efficient central organization, while the Middle Ages represented only decay in
civilization.
It has generally been supposed that a proper civilization started again only after the year 1000, which
represented a crucial moment in history: new technologies, the wider spread use of coins, economic
growth, and the founding of new market places. Therefore it became common to distinguish between the
Early and Late Middle Ages, separated by the eleventh century, as conventional reference. This flourishing
was supposed to have continued until the end of the Middle Ages and the start of the Renaissance,
traditionally fixed to the last twenty years of the fifteenth century.
But this was the traditional chronology, while according to more recent studies,
4
the period between the
Ennen ja nyt 4/2004 >>>
http://www.ennenjanyt.net/4-04/merchetti.pdf
4
fifth and the seventh centuries had a specific cultural context derived from a mixture of different elements:
Germanic and Eastern European elements brought to Italy with the barbarian invasions and preserved in
the Roman-Barbarian kingdoms; Oriental from the Eastern Roman Empire and Byzantium, whose soldiers
were a constant presence on Italian territory, as they had been ordered to restore the extension of the
Roman Empire.
Following these new definitions, scholars do not consider the year 1000 as crucial anymore. Today more
attention is given to finding a gradual transition between the Early and Late Middle Ages. Therefore it is
now generally supposed that the Early Middle Ages started around the eighth century and ended more or
less during the eleventh and the twelfth centuries.
The chronological definition of the Viking Age was no less problematic. Hence it has been suggested that
the definition of Viking Age be applied to the period between the first Danish and Norwegian raids in
Western Europe, about the 800, until the total collapse of Danish power in England, in the middle of the
eleventh century.
Viking raids are still a difficult phenomenon to explain, and therefore it has been suggested that the lack of
land and famine caused by huge demographic growth, induced a great part of the population to travel,
trade, and steal goods from other European countries.
5
But looking at the territorial situation of the Scandinavian countries, it seems that Denmark and Sweden
could offer enough cultivable land to the local population, maybe only in Norway could the situation be
problematic because a vast area of its territory is occupied by mountains.
Hence it was proposed that Vikings went to Western and Eastern Europe in order to collect precious
goods and establish new trading connections with other countries.
6
As proof of this theory could, in fact,
be seen that the most important consequence of the raids was the creation of a broad trade-network
involving Western (the British Isles, Frankia, the Low Countries, and Germany) and Eastern Europe
(Finland, the Baltic countries, and Russia), as well as the Atlantic regions (Iceland, Greenland, and Anse-
aux-Meadows in Canada).
7
Ennen ja nyt 4/2004 >>>
http://www.ennenjanyt.net/4-04/merchetti.pdf
5
Another important issue is represented by the conversion to Christianity, which was completed only in the
beginning of the Middle Ages (around the eleventh and twelfth centuries). Danish Vikings, the first
Scandinavians touched by conversion, were suspended between the traditional pagan religion and the new
imported cult. Moreover, around the eleventh and twelfth centuries important changes took place in
society and a new balance was established in the state.
8
It is interesting to note that after the process of conversion was completed, Vikings were involved in a
different kind of military expedition: crusades to convert Eastern Europe and the Baltic area to
Christianity. Therefore it seems that the Middle Ages in Scandinavia started at the latest in the twelfth
century, as proved by some relevant phenomena dated to that period:
9
1. The constitution of medieval states, which were the starting points for the modern ones.
2. The conversion of all Scandinavia to Christianity and the banishment of the old religion.
3. The end of the raids directed to Western Europe.
4. The permanent loss of the domination of the British Isles always contended between Denmark and
Norway.
Now, if I try to compare the chronological limits between the Viking Age in Denmark and the Early
Middle Ages in Italy it is possible to find a real correspondence: they more or less comprehended a period
between the eighth and the twelfth centuries, and this could be one point to consider in my research.
Considering the archaeological data it is possible to see that they present more or less the same
characteristics in both countries. Buildings and other structures were made of perishable materials,
therefore very little of them have been preserved until now, only negative impressions in the soil such as
post-holes, ditches or ground layers have survived. This means that the building quality was not generally
as good in Denmark as it was in Italy, although the quality was quite poor in both areas. The economic
investment in private houses was usually low and people often built their own houses. It also means that
methodological problems in studying and excavating Denmark and Italy are not very different.
My goal is to prove that, between the eighth and the twelfth centuries, a phenomenon of redefining the
settlement patterns happened in a similar way in both Denmark and Italy. I do not expect to find any direct
Ennen ja nyt 4/2004 >>>
http://www.ennenjanyt.net/4-04/merchetti.pdf
Plik z chomika:
lotgar
Inne pliki z tego folderu:
114_289_301.pdf
(2379 KB)
Viking Boat.pdf
(310 KB)
VIKING_TENT_FRAME.pdf
(217 KB)
vikingsb.pdf
(766 KB)
be15%20vikings%20and%20ireland.pdf
(577 KB)
Inne foldery tego chomika:
Arbman H. Birka
artykuły o wikingach
audiobook
broń
broń pdfy
Zgłoś jeśli
naruszono regulamin