Jiddu Krishnamurti - 12 - Collected Works 9 - The Answer Is In The Problem.pdf

(903 KB) Pobierz
AMSTERDAM 1ST PUBLIC TALK 17TH MAY
1955
One is apt rather to think that what is going to be said will be
oriental, and something which you have to struggle after to find.
You need not struggle; but I think it is important, if we wish to
understand each other, that we should first of all clear our minds of
obvious conclusions. I feel that what I am going to say is neither
oriental nor occidental. It is not something which, because I happen
to have a brown skin, is being brought from India for western
people to believe in. On the contrary, I think there is no east or
west when we are concerned with human problems. As we are
concerned with human problems, surely we must look at them
from no particular point of view, but comprehensively. If we look
at our human problems from a western point of view, or with the
attitude of an Indian, with certain traditions, ideas and beliefs, it
obviously prevents the comprehension of the total process of our
living. So it seems to me that it is very important not to assume
anything, not to draw upon any conclusion. or base our life on any
suppositions or postulates. That is one of our greatest difficulties, -
to free the mind from any assumption, from any belief, from all the
accretions of our own accumulated knowledge and all that we have
learned. Surely, if we would understand anything, we must have a
free mind, unburdened of any previous conclusions, unburdened of
all belief. When the mind is so free, unhampered by the various
conditionings which have been imposed on it, is it not possible that
such a mind is then capable of understanding the immediate
challenge of life, whatever it may be?
We are concerned, are we not? - not only here in Europe but
also in Asia and India - with a challenge that demands quite a
different approach from any method tried before. We have to
respond to the challenge of the present crisis, surely, with a total
mind, not with a fragmented mind, - not as Christians or Buddhists
or Hindus or Communists or Catholics or Protestants or what you
will. If we do so approach the challenge, from our own particular
standpoint, we shall fail, because the challenge is far too big, too
great, for us to respond to it partially, or with a mind conditioned
as a Christian or Buddhist or Hindu. So it seems to me that it is
very important to free the mind. and not to start from any premise,
from any conclusion. Because if we do start with any conclusion,
with any premise, we have already responded to the challenge
according to our own particular conditioning. So what is important,
if we are at all serious and earnest, is to ask ourselves whether the
mind can be unconditioned, and not merely seek to condition it into
a better, nobler pattern, - communist or socialist or catholic or what
you will. Most of us are concerned with how to condition the mind
into a nobler pattern; but can we not rather ask ourselves whether
the mind can really be unconditioned? It seems to me that if we are
at all serious, that is the fundamental issue. At present we are
approaching life, with its extraordinarily fundamental challenge,
either as a Christian, or as a Communist, or as a Hindu, or as a
Buddhist, or what you will, and so our response is always
conditioned, limited narrow and therefore our reaction to the
challenge is very petty. Therefore there is always conflict, there is
always sorrow, confusion. My response being inadequate,
insufficient, incomplete, must create within me a sense of conflict,
from which arises sorrow. Realizing that one suffers, one tries to
find a better, a nobler pattern of action, politically, or religiously,
or economically, but it is still, essentially, conditioned.
So surely, our problem is not the search for a better pattern
offered by one or the other of the various political or religious
groups. Nor can we return in our confusion to the past, as most
people are apt to do when they are confused, - go back to
something which we know, or which we have heard, or read of in
books, which again is the constant pursuit, is it not?, of a better,
nobler pattern of thinking, of conditioning. What we are talking
about here is an entirely different matter, - which is, is it possible
for the mind to be free, totally unconditioned? At present all our
minds are conditioned from the moment we are born to the
moment we die; our mind is shaped by circumstances, by society,
by religion, by education, by all the various pressures and strains of
life, moral, social, ethical, and all the rest of it. And, having been
shaped, we try to respond to something new; but obviously such a
response can never be complete. There is always a sense of failure,
of guilt, of misery. So, our question is then, is it not?, whether the
mind can be really free from all conditioning. And it seems to me
that it is really a very fundamental issue.
And if we are at all earnest, not only for the time being,
temporarily, but if we would maintain an earnestness to find out if
the mind can be free from all conditioning, that requires serious
attention. I do not think any book, any philosophy, any leader, any
teacher, is going to help us, for surely each one of us must find out
for ourselves whether the mind can be free. Some will say
"Obviously it cannot", and others may assert that it can. But both
Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin